5 reasons America needs a national carrier-selection standard now 

Why America needs a national carrier-selection standard

More than 1 million carrier-selection decisions are made every day without a clear federal standard for determining whether a trucking company is safe to hire. Congress and the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) have an opportunity, and an obligation, to provide that clarity.

That gap has become more consequential following the Supreme Court’s Montgomery decision. It illuminated that there is no single national standard defining the additional vetting processes businesses should undertake beyond federal safety determinations. Instead, interstate safety expectations are increasingly being shaped state by state, lawsuit by lawsuit and courtroom by courtroom.

That leaves businesses and freight brokers without a consistent benchmark for making carrier-selection decisions. A system that determines what constitutes “safe” carrier selection only after an accident does not provide the clarity needed to make informed decisions beforehand.

The need for a national standard is not about immunity from accountability. It is about creating clear, consistent rules that strengthen safety and accountability while protecting opportunities for qualified small businesses, keeping goods moving efficiently and strengthening a freight network that millions of people depend on every day.

Here are five reasons policymakers need to act now.

1. Clear standards can help lead to safer roads

A fragmented, subjective approach to carrier selection does not make the freight system safer. Unsafe trucking companies can still obtain freight, while qualified carriers may face higher costs and barriers unrelated to their safety performance. The goal should be clear, consistent standards that help prevent unsafe carrier selection in the first place, rather than relying on expanded legal exposure after an accident as a substitute for safety.

The federal safety-rating system illustrates the challenge. According to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce Institute for Legal Reform, 94.6% of regulated freight carriers have no formal FMCSA safety rating, and only 4% have a “satisfactory” rating. That’s not because most carriers are unsafe. FMCSA gives a rating only after it conducts a compliance review, and the agency does not have the staff, funding or resources to review more than a small share of carriers.

A “satisfactory” rating means FMCSA has conducted an audit and determined that the carrier has adequate safety-management controls to meet federal safety-fitness standards. Yet even that rating has been challenged in court as not meeting the standard of “reasonable care.”

And this is not a new problem. Nearly 12 years have passed since Congress directed FMCSA to overhaul its safety-rating system, yet that system still has not been reformed.

So where does that leave businesses and freight brokers? If hiring a federally authorized carrier isn’t enough, and even a satisfactory federal safety rating may not be enough, what standard should they follow?

A national carrier-selection standard could give businesses and freight brokers consistent criteria for evaluating trucking companies, supported by clear federal guidance and enforcement. Rather than determining what constitutes responsible carrier selection after the fact, the industry would have clear safety expectations to apply from the start.

To be clear: A national standard is not about immunity. It is about accountability. Companies should be held accountable when they fail to meet clear safety standards. But effective accountability starts with knowing what those standards are.

2. Small businesses are being squeezed

Small, family-owned businesses and independent operating trucking companies are the backbone of America’s freight network. Nearly 90% of trucking companies operate five trucks or fewer, while nearly 60% consist of a single owner operating a single truck.

C.H. Robinson has long championed the small carriers that keep freight moving, and America needs qualified carriers of every size to have the opportunity to compete, grow, and succeed to prevent supply chain failures. In the absence of a national carrier-selection standard, legal uncertainty can disproportionately affect the small businesses with the fewest resources to absorb it.

Qualified small carriers should not lose access to freight simply because policymakers have not provided clear criteria that can be followed with confidence. Clear national safety expectations can help qualified trucking companies, including small carriers, compete on a more consistent footing while supporting the safer, stronger freight network we all want.

3. Rising costs will not stay within the transportation industry

Legal uncertainty carries an economic cost, and it does not stop with trucking companies or freight brokers. Higher freight rates to ship goods paid by businesses will get passed on to consumers. Industry estimates of small to mid-sized freight brokers expect insurance premiums to increase more than 20% in the wake of Montgomery. Those pressures are building on costs that have already increased significantly.

According to the American Transportation Research Institute, average liability premiums for trucking companies increased 37.8% from 2015 to 2024, outpacing inflation and rising by more than 8 percent a year. Higher premiums put more pressure on smaller trucking companies, particularly those with fewer resources to absorb rising insurance and legal expenses.

When trucking capacity contracts and transportation costs rise, those pressures move through the supply chain. Businesses face higher costs to move their goods, and those higher costs can ultimately contribute to higher prices for consumers.

Transportation generally represents 9% to 14% of a product’s cost. The impact can be particularly meaningful for food, where retailers are among the biggest users of trucking services. The Federal Highway Administration estimates that every $1 of final demand for agricultural products requires 14.2 cents in transportation services.

That means pressures that begin in the freight industry can eventually show up for American families at the grocery store and in the cost of other everyday goods. According to the Chamber of Commerce, households could save more than $16.5 billion on food expenses if commercial-auto tort costs were reduced to the level of the least costly state, illustrating the broader economic stakes of rising transportation costs.

4. Commerce becomes less efficient

More than 23,000 freight brokers help businesses navigate a highly fragmented trucking market by providing the expertise, technology and access to capacity needed to match freight with qualified trucking companies.

Legal uncertainty complicates that role. Many businesses use a combination of trucking companies they work with directly and use freight brokers, meaning carrier-selection decisions occur across multiple parts of their supply chains. As legal risk grows, businesses are increasingly turning more of their shipping over to freight brokers while also consolidating freight with fewer brokers and providers.

A patchwork of standards can add costs, restrict access to capacity and make supply chains less reliable. A clear national standard would give businesses and their freight brokers consistent criteria for making carrier-selection decisions, helping preserve broad access to qualified trucking capacity and keeping essential goods moving safely and efficiently.

5. Businesses need clear, consistent rules

Businesses routinely manage risk and uncertainty. What is harder to manage is a standard that is not defined in advance. When the rules governing a fundamental business decision like moving goods safely can vary by jurisdiction or be determined through litigation after an accident, companies have less certainty about the decisions they make today.

That matters beyond any individual shipment. Businesses make long-term decisions about supply chains, transportation partners, technology, insurance and investment based on their ability to understand and manage risk. A safety standard should provide greater certainty, not introduce another variable that companies cannot reasonably anticipate or control.

For a national freight system, the rules for responsible carrier selection should be knowable and consistent nationwide. Congress and FMCSA have an opportunity to establish a durable federal framework that gives businesses confidence in how to make responsible decisions, gives trucking companies a clear standard to meet and keeps the focus where it belongs: on safer roads.

Dorothy Capers
Dorothy Capers Chief Legal Officer and Corporate Secretary
Stay up to date with our latest blog posts

Our supply chain experts share insights, best practices, and strategies to help you ship smarter.